• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Power Electronic Tips

Power Electronic News, Editorial, Video and Resources

  • Products
    • Power Supplies
    • AC-DC
    • DC-DC
    • MOSFETS
    • Power Management
    • Battery Management
    • RF Power
    • Resistors
    • Capacitors
    • Magnetics
    • Transformers
  • Applications
    • LED Lighting
    • Rack Mount
    • Wireless
  • EE Forums
    • EDABoard.com
    • Electro-Tech-Online.com
  • EE Learning Center
    • Design Guides
      • WiFi & the IOT Design Guide
      • Microcontrollers Design Guide
      • State of the Art Inductors Design Guide
  • Video
    • EE Videos
    • TI Power Videos
    • Teardown Videos
  • Resources
    • Design Fast
    • eBooks / Tech Tips
    • FAQ
    • LEAP Awards
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • White Papers

Why do we need all this LED driver stuff, anyway?

May 11, 2017 By Lee Teschler 6 Comments

The late Bob Pease, a venerated and well-liked engineer at National Semiconductor Corp. (now part of Texas Instruments) once wrote a series of technical musings inspired by questions that mostly younger engineers had to put to him somewhere along the line. We thought back to how Mr. Pease might have reacted when we noticed a recent comment posted in response to one of our teardowns involving 60-W LED bulbs:

To drive LEDs off the mains requires a transformer, bridge rectifier and a resistor! That’s all. The over complication makes for poor reliability when LEDs have an MTBF of around 200 years.

Well, not exactly.

This is a good opportunity to review the basics of why it is inadvisable to power an LED with just a bridge rectifier/transformer/resistor and why makes of LED bulbs are forced to go to some trouble in devising current sources comprised of a bit more than these three components.

It is often said that LEDs must be driven with current sources rather than voltage sources. The primary reason is that LED current varies with forward voltage, and LED light output varies with forward current. For a specific example, consider a Lumileds L150-xxxx500600000 LED, a device optimized for illumination applications. A 200-mV change in its forward voltage causes about a 100-mA change in its forward current. And a 100-mA change in its forward current causes about a 20% change in its light output.

These variations don’t make for high-quality illumination. This is largely why LED drivers are designed to deliver a constant current to the LED rather than a constant voltage.

As the comment writer suggested, the simplest way of setting the current to an LED is to put a properly sized resistor in series with it. However, modern LED supplies don’t do this. A simple example reveals why.

LED series resistorSuppose we have the same Lumileds LED mentioned above. Characteristic curves reveal the LED should carry about 650 mA to produce its rated light output and it should operate with a forward voltage of 6.1 V. For the sake of simplicity, assume the circuit contains only one Lumileds LED. Further suppose we use a 10-V supply. From Ohm’s law, the resistance in series with this 6.1-V LED needed to get 650 mA from a 10-V supply is 3.9/0.65 = 6 Ω because there must be a 3.9-V drop across the resistor. Thus the power dissipated in the resistor is 3.9 × 0.65 = 2.5 W. But the power dissipated in the LED is 6.1 × 0.65 = 4 W (in round numbers). So the combination dissipates 6.5 W, and the resistor dissipates almost 40% of the total power consumed here. Clearly, this isn’t a good state of affairs seeing as the rationale for replacing incandescent lights with LEDs is mainly one of better energy efficiency.

And it gets worse. Another drawback of a series resistance is an inability to closely control the current. LED forward voltage can vary from one unit to the next, so the voltage drop across any resistor put in series with the LED will vary as well. Thus as current can vary from one LED to another, so too will the light output.

home ever LED bulb
The LEDs on this plate from a 60-W equivalent bulb are all wired in series, in one string. This is pretty typical for inexpensive LED bulbs.

Of course, in the real world, most LED lighting products contain multiple LEDs. The drawbacks become more apparent when multiple LEDs are involved. In the example of the 10-V supply, the LEDs would necessarily be powered in parallel with power dissipated in multiple resistors and light output varying from one LED to another. (Note that real LED bulbs configure their LEDs in series, however.)

All these difficulties make it more feasible to drive LEDs with a constant-current power supply rather than a current-limiting resistor with a constant-voltage source. Again for reasons of energy efficiency, switch-mode power supplies are the topology of choice rather than linear supplies. The problem with linear supplies is that they all contain a variable-resistance pass element (i.e. a bipolar transistor or MOSFET) used to meter the load current (or load voltage for constant-voltage supplies). The power dissipated in the pass element can be significant.

linear supply topologyFor example, suppose we devise a linear supply by first putting ac from a wall socket through a classic full-wave bridge/smoothing-capacitor combo to get a dc level that is near 120 V. If our linear power supply operates in a constant-current mode, we now want to regulate the 120 V down to the 6.1-V/650 mA level needed to run the Lumiled LED without the series resistor. The power loss through the linear regulator is the difference between the input and output voltage multiplied by the load current. In this case, it is (120 – 6.1) ×0.65 = 74 W. Thus, we are losing 74 W in an effort to drive a 4-W LED.

Clearly, then, if your mission is to replace a 60-W incandescent bulb with a 4-W LED, a conventional linear supply won’t give you a bulb that is more energy efficient.

From the standpoint of energy efficiency, the appeal of a switching power supply is that its power loss doesn’t equal the difference between the input and output voltages multiplied by the load current, as in the case of a linear supply. The simplest model of a switching supply is one of a switch with two states, on and off, that chops the input voltage. The switch has a super-low on resistance, unlike the variable-resistance pass element used in the linear supply. To synthesize a steady output from the chopped waveform, an output filter is added. But the filter consists only of temporary energy storage elements, so it consists of nearly lossless components.

The combination of nearly lossless filtering and low-loss switching allow switching supplies to typically display energy efficiencies in the range of 90%. This is good enough for powering LEDs. The real trick is packing the power supply components into a container small enough to screw into an ordinary A19 light socket. As our teardowns of LED bulbs have shown, this is a feat that LED bulb makers achieve with a greater or lesser degree of elegance.

Filed Under: Featured, Lighting Tagged With: lumileds

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Mel Berman says

    May 11, 2017 at 6:35 pm

    Terrific article Lee!
    Best regards,
    Mel Berman
    Retired Power Electonics Tech Writer

  2. steve Taylor says

    May 24, 2017 at 8:26 pm

    Please don’t tell me a degree qualified engineer asked such a dumb question.

  3. Jerry B says

    May 25, 2017 at 9:12 am

    It’s kind of obvious for design engineers! Whether your considering power for LED’s or power for any electronics, the switch mode supply is more efficient then a linear supply. The trade off has always been the cost, parts count reliability etc.

  4. Xan says

    May 28, 2017 at 10:12 pm

    Well, some LED bulbs do not have a switchmode in them. They just have a simple capacitive dropper and a rectifier. If you have a much higher voltage than you need to drive the LED and a high value resistor, the output to the LED becomes nearly constant current. If we are using AC we can replace that resistor with the reactance of a capacitor and achieve a similar result with very little energy wasted across the cap. So why bother with the complexity of a switchmode, when it’s usually the first thing to fail in an LED bulb?

Trackbacks

  1. What’s all this stuff about capacitive power supplies for LEDs? - Power Electronic Tips says:
    June 15, 2017 at 10:38 am

    […] of these bulbs. We talked about some of the reasons these bulbs contain switching supplies in a previous article. But our latest post elicited this comment from another […]

  2. Top power electronics stories of 2017 - Power Electronic Tips says:
    December 31, 2017 at 1:08 pm

    […] Why do we need all this LED driver stuff, anyway? This is a good opportunity to review the basics of why it is inadvisable to power an LED with just a bridge rectifier/transformer/resistor and why makes of LED bulbs are forced to go to some trouble in devising current sources comprised of a bit more than these three components. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

CURRENT DIGITAL ISSUE

A frequency you can count on There are few constants in life, but what few there are might include death, taxes, and a U.S. grid frequency that doesn’t vary by more than ±0.5 Hz. However, the certainty of the grid frequency is coming into question, thanks to the rising percentage of renewable energy sources that…

More from the digital archive

DesignFast

Component Selection Made Simple.

Try it Today
design fast globle

Subscribe to our Newsletter

The Power Electronic eNewsletter delivers breaking electronic and power component news, resources, product innovations and more.

Subscribe today

EE TRAINING CENTER CLASSROOMS

EE Classrooms

RSS Current EDABoard.com discussions

  • How do you find the angle made by two isosceles triangles in a kite?
  • Thermal pad construction on pcb
  • FPGA LVDS with separate clock
  • Help understanding 915MHz transciever pcb layout
  • Ansys Electronic Desktop (HFSS) file opening failed????

RSS Current Electro-Tech-Online.com Discussions

  • Flickering (candle) LED to trigger 555
  • Identify a circuit.
  • Microcontrollable adjustable and switchable constant current source for driving LED's
  • Useful Handbook for Making Low Level Measurements
  • CRYPTOOOOO, but wait i am no terrorist

Footer

EE World Online Network

  • DesignFast
  • EE World Online
  • EDA Board Forums
  • Electro Tech Online Forums
  • Connector Tips
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Analog IC Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Test and Measurement Tips
  • Wire and Cable Tips
  • 5G Technology World

Power Electronic Tips

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • About us
Follow us on TwitterAdd us on FacebookFollow us on YouTube Follow us on Instagram

Copyright © 2022 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy