• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Power Electronic Tips

Power Electronic News, Editorial, Video and Resources

  • Products
    • Power Supplies
    • AC-DC
    • DC-DC
    • MOSFETS
    • Power Management
    • Battery Management
    • RF Power
    • Resistors
    • Capacitors
    • Magnetics
    • Transformers
  • Applications
    • LED Lighting
    • Rack Mount
    • Wireless
  • EE Forums
    • EDABoard.com
    • Electro-Tech-Online.com
  • EE Learning Center
  • Video
    • EE Videos
    • TI Power Videos
    • Teardown Videos
  • Resources
    • Design Fast
    • eBooks / Tech Tips
    • FAQ
    • LEAP Awards
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • White Papers

Flow battery application challenges and considerations – Virtual Roundtable (part 2 of 2)

September 12, 2020 By Jeff Shepard Leave a Comment

In this second part of EEWorld’s “virtual roundtable” discussion on flow batteries, our panelists delve into the impact that the emergence of flow batteries is having on energy storage compared with conventional rechargeable batteries: What factors determine when flow batteries are more cost-effective than rechargeable batteries? How do the maintenance and monitoring needs of flow batteries compare with the needs of rechargeable batteries? And what are the barriers to using blow batteries in transportation applications such as electric vehicles, electric trains, or electric ships? Joining us for this virtual roundtable are: Olaf Conrad (OC), Managing Director with JenaBatteries, a maker of metal-free redox flow batteries. And Bruce Herzer (BH), Director of Marketing with Invinity Energy Systems, a maker of Vanadium flow batteries.

JS: What are the main challenges users face when first developing flow battery installations?

Olaf Conrad (OC), Managing Director with JenaBatteries

OC: Authorities are still very unfamiliar with flow batteries. Therefore, getting all permissions that are required for a first flow battery installation is the single-most-important challenge for any user. Several pilot installations have been realized in all major economic regions so that the body of documented permission records is growing. Currently, knowing how to plot the path to a fully permitted installation is seen as a competitive advantage, but in short order norms and standards as well as regulatory frameworks will guide even the inexperienced user.

BH: We think that the main challenges are receding. Many flow battery deployments in the past have been built in place as bespoke projects, with testing and electrolyte filling done on-site. This has added to project complexity and uncertainty. We’ve developed the technology to the point today where we’re shipping turn-key, fully tested, fully-manufactured batteries out of our factories. This has fundamentally shifted vanadium flow into the realm of “plug and play” in the same way that lithium batteries can be installed within hours.

Bruce Herzer (BH), Director of Marketing with Invinity Energy Systems

JS: What is the critical use-case factor, or factors, that determine when flow batteries are more cost-effective compared with rechargeable batteries?

BH: We look for a variety of project characteristics that indicate flow will be the best technology choice.  One is the expected use: flow works great in scenarios where the batteries will need to deliver over 300 annual cycles of 2 hours or more or over 600 annual cycles of under 2 hours. Another good fit is commercial or industrial sites that use solar generation and have 24×7 consumption; in those cases, the longer duration flow can deliver comes into play. Generally speaking, most of the projects where we see great ROI involve the pairing of intermittent renewable generation with storage systems.

OC: Once flow batteries have proven their projected longevity, 10,000 to 20,000 full cycles, and 10 to 20 years calendar life, flow batteries will almost always be the more cost-effective technology for grid-level before-the-meter and behind-the-meter installations.

Invinity Vanadium flow batteries in a solar farm.

JS: How do the monitoring and maintenance requirements of flow batteries differ from the needs of rechargeable batteries?

OC: Flow batteries have pumps, sensors, piping, and tanks and will therefore require regular inspections and maintenance akin to the well-established schemes for storage tank installations. On the other hand, flow batteries have no issues with unbalanced cells, cell voltage monitoring, and the critical monitoring and control of thermal runaway incidents.

JennaBatteries metal-free redox flow batteries in a wind farm.

BH: Like any storage system, VFBs have a regular maintenance schedule as subsystems like pumps and tubing should be replaced over time. The big difference with lithium is the electrolyte–the liquid vanadium electrolyte doesn’t degrade. In contrast, lithium systems are typically augmented after 5 years because of degradation–meaning cells need to be swapped out and replaced, or new cells are added to the degraded ones to get the capacity back up to where it was.

Another difference is in the complexity and archiving of monitoring data.  Lithium battery operators need to store a huge amount of data in case they ever need to make a warranty claim because they have to prove that every cell in the array has been operated within the prescribed parameters since the day it was installed. There’s no need to monitor VFBs at the cell level, and that data doesn’t need to be archived to satisfy the warranty conditions because the terms are far more flexible.

JS: What are the challenges to be overcome if flow batteries are to be used in applications such as electric vehicles, electric trains, or electric ships?

BH: The big issue here is energy density and weight which we don’t think to make vanadium flow batteries practical for these applications today, although there are some interesting inland shipping concepts out there. Inevitably, as the VFB technology matures further, we’ll see energy density increase, just as it has with lithium over the last 20 years. But I think flow-powered transportation is decades away if it ever happens. In the meantime, flow batteries have plenty of room to grow in land-based projects where space and weight don’t factor in.

OC: Most importantly: Energy density. In my mind of equal importance is the need for fail-proof prevention of spills. Jenabatteries does not pursue motive applications, because spill-prevention becomes incredibly more difficult for moving installations.

You may also like:


  • Flow battery capabilities and performance – Virtual Roundtable (part 1…
  • flow batteries
    Flow batteries – What’s ahead?
  • flow batteries
    Flow batteries – What can you use them for?
  • flow batteries
    How do flow batteries work?

Filed Under: Battery, FAQ, Featured Tagged With: FAQ

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

DesignFast

Component Selection Made Simple.

Try it Today
design fast globle

Subscribe to our Newsletter

The Power Electronic eNewsletter delivers breaking electronic and power component news, resources, product innovations and more.

Subscribe today

Test & Measurement Handbook


EE TRAINING CENTER CLASSROOMS

“ee

“ee

“ee

“ee

RSS Current EDABoard.com discussions

  • Super capacitor to make 24v
  • Deviation of dain current of PA between simulation and measurement
  • using shift register for extend output is Safe ?
  • 3n211 dual gate mosfet modern replacement
  • ADS Optimize erroe

RSS Current Electro-Tech-Online.com Discussions

  • Honey amp - diy guitar amp kit
  • Re:paralleled PWM ESCs
  • Simple class A amplifier how it works
  • Touch circuit sound, led. 555 timer
  • new to Ardunio but trying to compile

Follow us on Twitter

Tweets by PowerElectrTips

Footer

EE World Online Network

  • DesignFast
  • EE World Online
  • EDA Board Forums
  • Electro Tech Online Forums
  • Connector Tips
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Analog IC Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Test and Measurement Tips
  • Wire and Cable Tips
  • 5G Technology World

Power Electronic Tips

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • About us
Follow us on TwitterAdd us on FacebookFollow us on YouTube Follow us on Instagram

Copyright © 2021 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy