• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Power Electronic Tips

Power Electronic News, Editorial, Video and Resources

  • Products
    • Power Supplies
    • AC-DC
    • DC-DC
    • MOSFETS
    • Power Management
    • Battery Management
    • RF Power
    • Resistors
    • Capacitors
    • Magnetics
    • Transformers
  • Applications
    • LED Lighting
    • Rack Mount
    • Wireless
  • EE Forums
    • EDABoard.com
    • Electro-Tech-Online.com
  • EE Learning Center
  • Video
    • EE Videos
    • TI Power Videos
    • Teardown Videos
  • Resources
    • Design Fast
    • eBooks / Tech Tips
    • FAQ
    • LEAP Awards
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • White Papers

Energy storage by the Farad, Part 2: Supercapacitors & batteries

June 24, 2021 By Bill Schweber Leave a Comment

For operating and backup power and energy storage, engineers can choose among batteries, supercapacitors, or “best of both” hybrid supercapacitors.

The previous part of this article established the context for supercapacitors and explained their structure in simplistic terms; obviously, this is a component with deep physics, chemistry, materials-science considerations, and manufacturing issues. The first widely used standard supercapacitors reached the market in the late 1970 and early 1980s. They were used primarily for memory backup of volatile memory, but they did not have mass-market acceptance due to cost and performance issues. However, by the 1990s, supercapacitors were available at modest cost and with superior performance and reliability, and so began to be routinely designed into systems. The relevant Wikipedia reference is fairly detailed on their history and, equally important, cites many reputable sources, including news in the trade media and papers from academic journals as this happened.

Supercapacitor characteristics

Among their other differences, supercapacitors’ charge/discharge characteristics differ from those of batteries, regardless of battery chemistry (and note that each rechargeable battery chemistry has its own charge/discharge-curve profile). Figure 1 is a general curve of the charge (top) and discharge (bottom) profile for these devices.

Fig: (top) The voltage/current charge (top) and discharge (bottom) profiles for the supercapacitor are very different than the ones associated with most rechargeable batteries, such as Li-ion-based units. (Image: Battery University)

As with batteries or even non-supercapacitors, there is no “typical” supercapacitor, but a representative family can provide an overview of their basic characteristics. For example, the HB series of cylindrical supercapacitors from Eaton is a family of leaded devices for through-hole PC-board mounting with 2.5 V output (Figure 2). The family members range in capacitance and size from 3 farads in a 21-mm long, 8-mm diameter package to 110 F in a 60-mm long, 18-mm diameter package. Supercapacitors are also available in “coin” packages for compatibility with coin-cell sockets.

Fig 2: Despite their much-higher farad rating, supercapacitors look like conventional capacitors and with comparable dimensions and packaging, and these leaded units show. (Image: Eaton)

Other important parameters of these supercapacitors are their equivalent series resistance (ESR) ranging from 0.16 ohms down to 0.020 ohms for the largest, pulse current of 1 A up to 24 A, and continuous current of 1.1 A up to 8.7 A for the smallest to the largest versions, respectively.

What about batteries?

Since their commercialization, supercapacitors have found major use for delivering continuous power as well as short-term energy storage in power backup, energy harvesting, and pulse-power delivery applications. For some of these situations, batteries alone would be perhaps good, but some of their inherent characteristics would make them less suitable. Supercapacitors are used individually in small-scale, very low-power applications such as harvesting/IoT modules. They are also in series/parallel combinations as capacitor power banks for large-scale UPS installations. They are especially useful in providing “bridge” power in mission-critical such as hospitals to keep power available (through an inverter) between the time primary power fails and the backup-generator is activated.

Any general comparison of supercapacitors with rechargeable batteries is just that: a generalization, since so much depends on the specific battery type being compared. Nonetheless, the table of (Figure 4) gives a good overall idea of the relative attributes of supercapacitor versus Li-ion batteries. However, the capabilities and specifics of both technologies are always changing and advancing as well, of course – so use the table only as a rough guide and starting point.

Fig 3: This comparison between top-level characteristics of supercapacitors and lithium-based rechargeable cells is a starting-point generalization, as there are many variations along with constant advances for both. (Image: Battery University)

The third part of this article looks into component management and the fascinating hybrid supercapacitor/lithium cell device.

EE World Related Content

Supercapacitor line now ranges from coin cell, radial form factors, large snap-in types
Supercapacitors operate at 3 and 6 V
What’s new in electrolytic capacitors and supercapacitors for energy harvesting
Supercapacitor system design considerations
Supercapacitor specifications and lifetimes – Virtual Roundtable (part 2 of 2)
Supercapacitor ESR and optimal performance – Virtual Roundtable (part 1 of 2)
Supercapacitor specifications and IEC/EN 62391–1
Supercapacitor operation – a higher power source
Applying large banks of supercapacitors

 

External References

Wikipedia, “Supercapacitor”
Eaton, “Hybrid supercapacitors explained”
Eaton, “HS Hybrid supercapacitor white paper”
Eaton,  “Supercapacitor back up power solutions”
Eaton,  “HB Supercapacitors Cylindrical cells” (supercapacitor datasheet)
Eaton, “HS/HSL Hybrid Supercapacitors” (hybrid supercapacitor datasheet)
Battery University (Cadex), “BU-209: How does a Supercapacitor Work?”
Taiyo Yuden, “Lithium Ion Capacitors: The Ultimate EDLC Replacement”
Taiyo Yuden, “Power Storage Devices: Lithium Ion Capacitors;Electric Double-Layer Capacitors”
Tech Briefs, “Supercapacitors Go Hybrid for Increased Performance and Efficiency
Kemet, “Supercapacitors vs. batteries”
Illinois Capacitor, “Supercapacitors”
Basic Electronics 16, “Supercapacitors”
Jinzhou Kaimei Power Co., Ltd. “The Supercapacitors: its Basic Principles, Classification, and its Electrical Performance”

 

You may also like:

  • supercapacitors
    Energy storage by the Farad, Part 3: Hybrid supercapacitors
  • supercapacitor basics
    Energy storage by the Farad, Part 1: Supercapacitor basics
  • lithium batteries
    Battery chemistries that excel in inaccessible applications

  • Supercapacitor specifications and IEC/EN 62391–1

  • Supercapacitor operation – a higher power source

Filed Under: batteries, Battery Management, Capacitors, FAQ, Featured, Power Components, Power Management, supercapacitors Tagged With: FAQ

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

CURRENT DIGITAL ISSUE

Featuring 15 articles, the 2022 5G Handbook looks at private networks, timing, connectivity, latency, mmWaves, test, and other topics.

More from the digital archive

DesignFast

Component Selection Made Simple.

Try it Today
design fast globle

Subscribe to our Newsletter

The Power Electronic eNewsletter delivers breaking electronic and power component news, resources, product innovations and more.

Subscribe today

EE TRAINING CENTER CLASSROOMS

EE Classrooms

RSS Current EDABoard.com discussions

  • A circuit that can adjust a resistance and probing a voltage node
  • DC to DC buck converter
  • A circuit that can probe 2 currents and adjust the resistor
  • Microsoft Project 2019 dependencies
  • MOSFET ORing circuit simulation (LTspice)

RSS Current Electro-Tech-Online.com Discussions

  • Enclosure sought
  • Need help using a common power supply for two devices
  • Fletcher's Law
  • Setting the 18F24K20 to digital.
  • Multistage BJT amplifier

Footer

EE World Online Network

  • DesignFast
  • EE World Online
  • EDA Board Forums
  • Electro Tech Online Forums
  • Connector Tips
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Analog IC Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Test and Measurement Tips
  • Wire and Cable Tips
  • 5G Technology World

Power Electronic Tips

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • About us
Follow us on TwitterAdd us on FacebookFollow us on YouTube Follow us on Instagram

Copyright © 2022 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy